south.asia (home) | sub.gate | collaborative(s) | mail.lists | about | search - 
 
 
List co-ordinated with... AZ: Glossolalia, "speaking in tongues"...
Architexturez > Mail > [ In-Enaction ] Re: superStar hyperbole: OMA in Beijing (critique) [ .US ]

List Information Page (subscribe to this list here) + … search this list + RSS Feed

message ## 02360… switch to: Subject Directory | Date Directory | Author Directory -
<< Thread Prev < Date Prev ^ date index +… ^ thread index +… Date Next > Thread Next >>
+  From: "Architexturez." <interface.services@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
+  Date: Mon, 27 Nov 2006 14:12:04 +0530
ref http://mail.architexturez.net/+/In-Enaction/archive/msg01472.shtml

and

ref http://www.surveillance-and-society.org/issue2(2)abstracts.htm :-)

| contains some precedent analysis

Architexturez. wrote:
OMA in Beijing: China Central Television Headquarters by Ole Scheeren and Rem Koolhaas
Architecture and Design Galleries

November 15, 2006–February 26, 2007


It is in a similar spirit that the firm has designed the nearby Television Cultural Center (TVCC) Building, which looks like a punctuated, multi-tiered skiramp. Unlike the larger CCTV Building, however, which is mainly for professionals working in the Chinese television industry, this structure is an entirely public space containing cultural facilities and a luxury hotel.

At the core of both buildings, however, is a lie that goes to the heart of almost every Deconstructivist project ever built: Its daring, rebellious formal statement is really no more integral to the project as a whole than a chassis is to a car. One of the exhibition wall texts is at pains to assure us that "the two towers (of the TVCC) slope six degrees in two directions, while their internal cores remain completely vertical." In other words, under the post-modern carapace of these two towers lurks something suspiciously like the standard glass and steel towers of Midtown.

You will excuse me, I hope, if I pass over in silence OMA's expensive talk about society and capitalism and the projection onto the entire site of Piranesi's 18th-century map of Rome. All of that, together with the curators' claim that "CCTV is the creation of an entire world," can be pretty much discarded. One's assessment of this latest project from OMA is predicated upon one's entirely personal tolerance and indulgence of the intentional bulk and clumsiness of the complex as a whole. For my part, I should rather have designed La Defense.

cont'd....
http://www.nysun.com/article/43671?page_no=2


Previous by Thread: superStar hyperbole: OMA in Beijing
Next by Thread: Re: superStar hyperbole: OMA in Beijing (critique) [ .US ]
Partial thread listing: