south.asia (home) | sub.gate | collaborative(s) | mail.lists | about | search - 
 
 
List co-ordinated with... AZ: Glossolalia, "speaking in tongues"...
Architexturez > Mail > [ In-Enaction ] cons: 'Progress' May Hurt the Taj

List Information Page (subscribe to this list here) + … search this list + RSS Feed

message ## 02632… switch to: Subject Directory | Date Directory | Author Directory -
<< Thread Prev < Date Prev ^ date index +… ^ thread index +… Date Next > Thread Next >>
+  From: "Architexturez." <interface.services@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
+  Date: Tue, 20 Feb 2007 11:13:19 +0530
Preservationists Worry 'Progress' May Hurt Indian Heritage Site
By Steve Herman
New Delhi
19 February 2007

....

Architects on both sides of the controversy worry that politics, not science, will determine how close the improved road comes to the historic sites. Indian media report that the prime minister's office has now asked to review the plans.

Patwant Singh says the fact that the Mughals were Muslims, a minority in modern-day India, might play a role in the decision. He wonders aloud whether greater care would be taken if the monuments were linked to the country's majority Hindus.

But architect Sinha bristles at the suggestions that religion might be a deciding factor.

"We have never, never, never for that matter, looked at the heritage properties from that angle, because a heritage is a heritage whether it is Hindu, Christian, Muslim, Sikh or for that matter any other religion," he said.

Just how close the construction comes to Emperor Humayun's mausoleum could ultimately be determined by the United Nations Education, Scientific and Cultural Organization. UNESCO, if duly concerned, could declare that the construction endangers the World Heritage Site.

Such an action, conservationists here say, would pressure the city government to detour the road project farther away from the historic monument.


cont'd....
http://www.voanews.com/english/2007-02-19-voa10.cfm

=============

media: http://www.voanews.com/mediaassets/english/2007_02/Audio/rm/herman_india_reservation_19feb07.rm


Previous by Thread: Re: cons: Prisoners to restore heritage structures
Next by Thread: cons: Protest the tomb-tunnel road
Partial thread listing: