south.asia (home) | sub.gate | collaborative(s) | mail.lists | about | search - 
 
 
List co-ordinated with... AZ: Glossolalia, "speaking in tongues"...
Architexturez > Mail > [ In-Enaction ] uglificiation: Anything beautiful in Calcutta is targeted by apathy and avarice (!)

List Information Page (subscribe to this list here) + … search this list + RSS Feed

message ## 03419… switch to: Subject Directory | Date Directory | Author Directory -
<< Thread Prev < Date Prev ^ date index +… ^ thread index +… Date Next > Thread Next >>
+  From: Architexturez-IN <admin-in@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
+  Date: Sun, 23 Sep 2007 11:48:13 +0530
As a Calcutta boy, I grew up hating the superciliousness of south Bombay brats convinced they were living at the centre of the Indian universe, and living as far away as was possible from the stinky armpit that was Calcutta; as an adult, I’ve suffered the patronizing tones of Delhiites as they explained to me how marginal my hometown actually was. My internal defence to all this was always the wit, the remnants of beauty, and the psychic and human scale of my city. Now that all that is nearly gone, I am left without any argument. In this, the real chagrin for someone like me is that DNGD and even Bombay-Navi Mumbai might soon be far more beautiful, and far nicer places to live in than Calcutta, not just for the rich but also for lower-middle-income groups and the working class.

Using it’s own construction of the ‘working class’, this government can rail against the United States of America. Jyoti Basu can come out of retirement to protest against joint military exercises with the US and the 123 ‘sell-out’. The national government can be threatened by the hubris of old and not so old comrades. But what about the ugly Amerification of this town? What about the butchering of beauty by the basest ‘American’ instincts that Jyotibabu himself inaugurated and presided over, and that his successors are continuing with such energy? Will this city be an original, humanist beacon of urban planning, a place of light and laughter showing the way to its neighbours Patna, Bhubaneshwar, Dhaka, Guwahati, Rangoon and Bangkok? Like hell it will. Once the people in power used to replicate spent ideas from China and the Soviet Union, but now what Calcutta is becoming is the worst of America. If we continue the way we are going then, in about 15 years, this city will resemble nothing so much as an aesthetic Chernobyl crossed with a beat-up, shabbier version of downtown Milwaukee.

cont'd....
http://www.telegraphindia.com/1070923/asp/opinion/story_8335473.asp

Previous by Thread: Re: Uffizi: Expansion: goes ahead despite Florentine opposition
Next by Thread: ugly architecture: Buildings Only an Architect Could Love
Partial thread listing: